Disney's Old Key West Resort Reviews ( 88/100 )



Disney's Old Key West Resort Reviews Breakdown:
  • Check-In Process: 4/5
  • Service and Cast Members: 5/5
  • Room Cleanliness: 23/25
  • Room Decor: 9/10
  • Lobby / Common Areas: 4/5
  • Hotel Condition / Cleanliness: 14/15
  • Dining Options: 4/5
  • Pools and Recreation: 8/10
  • Transportation: 7/10
  • Value: 9/10

Individual Old Key West Reviews (77)
Check-In Service Common Areas Hotel Condition Dining Rec. Trans.
4/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 5/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 97%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: I love this resort! It definitely feels like a home away from home due to being a dedicated DVC resort. With the latest refurbishment, it’s hard to believe it’s been around for over 20 years. There’s a different vibe to this resort. Slow paced and relaxed. It has a historical feel to it (just take the Conch Flats Tour to find out) the backstory extends from the architecture down to the amazing dishes served at Olivia’s. Even the Gurgling Suitcase Bar gets in on tale and is about the size of most Key West bars. The cast members feel like old friends and the boat ride down the river to Disney Springs is so relaxing. The rooms are so large, it definitely makes you want to fill out a change of address form and call this place home.

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 3/5 8/10 8/10
  • Rating: 94%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: I was definitely surprised and pleased with the resort. The room was amazing and very large. The staff was great. My only complaint is that is doesn't feel very "Disney" themed. We had a great week there.

5/5 5/5 5/5 9/15 2/5 8/10 8/10
  • Rating: 78%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 20/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Maybe
  • Value for the Money: 8/10

  • Overall Impression: very nice spread out but lack of quick food places

5/5 3/5 5/5 15/15 5/5 10/10 10/10
  • Rating: 98%
  • Room Type: Three Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10
5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 5/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 98%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: I am coming back this is the hotel I usually come o.

4/5 4/5 4/5 12/15 4/5 6/10 8/10
  • Rating: 80%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 20/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Maybe
  • Value for the Money: 8/10
5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 8/10 10/10
  • Rating: 97%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10
4/5 4/5 4/5 15/15 4/5 6/10 N/A
  • Rating: 92%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Newly remodeled spacious rooms and excellently maintained grounds. A fantastic option for a resort stay.

4/5 4/5 3/5 12/15 3/5 8/10 N/A
  • Rating: 75%
  • Room Type: Three Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 15/25
  • Room Decor: 6/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: We love the relaxed feel this resort offers, and we enjoy the huge balconies with dining tables. Also, it was not an option that I could see in the drop down menu, but we were in a one-bedroom. The only option I could see on the form was a three-bedroom.

5/5 4/5 4/5 15/15 3/5 8/10 10/10
  • Rating: 86%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 6/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 6/10

  • Overall Impression: This is a very nice resort and felt very laid back. Bus service was outstanding by Turtle pond area. Olivias was great. Room was very clean. Some things we did not like was our room had the old safe with a Key! Not sure why they didnt upgrade to a newer safe. Also the Ice machines are far away from the rooms. They are in the middle of the road at the bus stops.

5/5 4/5 3/5 15/15 3/5 8/10 4/10
  • Rating: 87%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Maybe
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: If we were able to book HH room category, I think most of our problems would have been alleviated. The resort amenities are lovely and the grounds put me in the mood for a relaxing vacation. The cast members are all super nice. But, the resort is sprawling and we felt lost in the shuffle in the bus system. Being near the Hospitality House would put us closer to the best things about the resort and in a place with better bus coverage.

5/5 5/5 4/5 12/15 3/5 8/10 8/10
  • Rating: 90%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Was a really nice place, and is our "Home" DVC resort. It was our first stay as DVC members and we had a 3 Bedroom Villa. I would highly recommend for family stays.

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 3/5 10/10 2/10
  • Rating: 88%
  • Room Type: Three Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Maybe
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: We really liked everything except the wait for bus service. Other than that we would definitely stay again. LOVED the cast members and the overall atmosphere!

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 10/10 4/10
  • Rating: 83%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 4/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 6/10

  • Overall Impression: The cast members here are without compare. The day we were scheduled to leave, my dad was admitted to the hospital in Celebration. The front desk managers could not have been more helpful or accommodating in helping me find another room, and then moving me twice, after the first room was occupied, and the air conditioning was broken in the next. They even called me twice just to follow up and see how my father was.

5/5 5/5 4/5 15/15 4/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 94%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Really nice and relaxing. First time staying there, and I was impressed!

5/5 5/5 4/5 15/15 3/5 6/10 8/10
  • Rating: 91%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Great resort with a relaxed vibe. Definitely staying again.

5/5 5/5 4/5 15/15 4/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 96%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Loved this resort. It would probably be our second choice for a future stay

4/5 5/5 4/5 15/15 3/5 8/10 4/10
  • Rating: 86%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 8/10

  • Overall Impression: Very good. Always a good option when we want to save DVC points.

4/5 5/5 4/5 15/15 4/5 10/10 4/10
  • Rating: 82%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 20/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 8/10
5/5 5/5 4/5 15/15 3/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 95%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Maybe
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Old Key West is a beautiful sprawling resort, but I did not like how large it was and how far you could be away from everything. I did love the boat to Disney Springs, but I’m not sure I would stay again unless I was going with a large group of people, it was a little isolating.

5/5 5/5 4/5 12/15 4/5 8/10 10/10
  • Rating: 83%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 15/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: I love Old Key West

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 5/5 10/10 10/10
  • Rating: 100%
  • Room Type: Three Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10
5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 8/10 10/10
  • Rating: 97%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10
3/5 4/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 6/10 8/10
  • Rating: 86%
  • Room Type: Three Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 8/10

  • Overall Impression: As a DVC member we love the size of the rooms and the overall looks of the resort. It is always great looking and well maintained

2/5 4/5 5/5 12/15 4/5 10/10 10/10
  • Rating: 92%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Resorts was very nice, way to big but it always beautiful, clean and quiet ! I have stayed there 4 times

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 97%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10
5/5 5/5 4/5 15/15 3/5 6/10 N/A
  • Rating: 91%
  • Room Type: Three Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Nice for adults being able to have own bedroom.

3/5 5/5 5/5 12/15 2/5 6/10 N/A
  • Rating: 84%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Maybe
  • Value for the Money: 6/10

  • Overall Impression: I like the tranquility of the resort. We have stayed her several times. I just believe the place needs a bit more TLC, more dining options and better parking. We like Saratoga Springs because it has pull through parking (2 deep) and it makes parking with the Disability Trailer so much easier. To park at Old Key West we have to take up 3 regular parking spaces so we have enough room to exit when we need too.

1/5 2/5 3/5 12/15 1/5 8/10 2/10
  • Rating: 58%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 15/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? No
  • Value for the Money: 6/10

  • Overall Impression: Absolutely horrible

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 97%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Amazing. We stayed here because we were trying to save on points because we went more often this past year and were low. This resort is now our favorite for this type of trip. It felt like a vacation. If you are a family with small children AND have a car, this is the perfect resort.

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 5/5 10/10 10/10
  • Rating: 100%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: The only complaint is that cast members parked in the spots reserved for guests. Many times we had to park a distance from our villa because housekeeping staff used all the spots even tho there was cast member parking right next to our area. We mentioned it several times and were told it was addressed but it never changed.

2/5 3/5 4/5 9/15 4/5 6/10 4/10
  • Rating: 61%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 15/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 6/10

  • Overall Impression: Upon checking-in, our room smelled of cigarettes so bad that I had to make note with front desk so that they would not charge me a cleaning fee when we checked out. One portion of coffee for a three day stay and it was de-caffinated at that. Only 3 towels left in room for four registered guests for three days. Water pressure was non existent in shower. Has to be a management issue cause I stayed there for ten days this past summer and had two major issues then as well (no hot water for an entire day and the shower handle literally fell off). Not one courtesy call, ever.

5/5 4/5 5/5 15/15 2/5 6/10 8/10
  • Rating: 90%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: We are DVC and booked 6.5 months out, so our home resorts were full (Copper Creek and Boardwalk). We heard that OKW was "consolation prize" so we were a little reluctant. But we really, really liked it! It has a great vibe, comfortable rooms, etc. We would choose to stay here again.

5/5 5/5 3/5 12/15 4/5 8/10 8/10
  • Rating: 83%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 20/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Very nice grounds. Well maintained. Nice Home feeling.

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 5/5 8/10 8/10
  • Rating: 89%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 20/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Old Key West is a pleasant resort. I enjoyed being so close Disney Springs and having easy access to transportation (our room was the first bus stop at night). I would definitely stay here again.

5/5 5/5 4/5 15/15 5/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 90%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 20/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 8/10

  • Overall Impression: Very clean and well laid out. Good value!

2/5 4/5 5/5 15/15 2/5 6/10 4/10
  • Rating: 83%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: We had issues at check-in and were not notified by 4pm that our room was ready. Despite that, I would stay here again because we loved the villa itself, rooms are typically available, and the points are cheap. I wish there were more/better dining options for quick service. I also wish the bus service ran more efficiently. In the future, we would request a room closer to the Hospitality House to cut down on the transportation issues.

4/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 10/10 10/10
  • Rating: 98%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: I was ready to buy points at Key West after the stay if I had the money to do so, we will be back here again!

5/5 5/5 4/5 12/15 4/5 10/10 10/10
  • Rating: 87%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 6/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 6/10
5/5 4/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 8/10 10/10
  • Rating: 96%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: We love Millers Road area and this is our second choice every time to our home resort of Boardwalk

4/5 5/5 3/5 9/15 4/5 6/10 4/10
  • Rating: 67%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 20/25
  • Room Decor: 6/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? No
  • Value for the Money: 6/10

  • Overall Impression: Nice resort, quaint. I much prefer the room to open into a hallway, and having a grand lobby is my favorite. I thought the resort was very cute, staff was nice.

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 5/5 10/10 10/10
  • Rating: 100%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Old key west is great.. our favorite resort!

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 5/5 8/10 8/10
  • Rating: 92%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 8/10

  • Overall Impression: Love the resort. We had a 2 bedroom it was very nice, there are 8 of us, 6 adults and 2 children. Love that we can cook in the room for breakfast and a couple of meals, but still enjoy eating on property trying different places. Having laundry in room is very convenient.

5/5 5/5 4/5 6/15 4/5 8/10 8/10
  • Rating: 81%
  • Room Type: Three Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 8/10

  • Overall Impression: We have stayed in a grand villa in OKW before and I love it to have our whole family together.

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 3/5 10/10 10/10
  • Rating: 98%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Beautiful resort, with "laid back" being a very good description. The rooms are big, the landscaping beautiful. A real pleasure to stay at.

5/5 4/5 4/5 15/15 4/5 6/10 8/10
  • Rating: 89%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 8/10

  • Overall Impression: We loved our room and stay at old key west. If it had a couple

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 5/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 98%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: This is my DVC home resort. I love it here. The ambience, size of room and being able to park close by are big bonuses for my family.

4/5 4/5 3/5 15/15 2/5 8/10 8/10
  • Rating: 83%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 6/10
5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 3/5 8/10 8/10
  • Rating: 94%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: This resort was SUPER nice and laid out really well. Felt like home.

4/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 96%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Old Key West is a beautiful and well-maintained resort. The rooms are spacious, well-appointed, and comfortable. I also have to say we encountered some of the friendliest and most helpful cast members ever at this resort. We must also share this story. Two weeks before we arrived, our daughter started having nightmares every night waking her up in tears. We had booked a one bedroom with the plan that she would sleep in the couch pull out. After a full day of traveling, we experienced the sad event of our 8-month-old waking up the 3-year-old and the 3-year-old then waking up the 8-month-old all night long. Needless to say there was almost no sleep the first night. In a tired haze, I called the Front Desk in the morning and requested a two bedroom at any cost. They explained they were fully booked but would look to see what they could do for us. Within 20 minutes, a great cast member named Chris called back to say that someone had booked and paid for a room but never showed so the planned to default on the room. He asked us to be patient for an hour while he had someone run over to check it (since it was already clean). By the end of that hour, bell service had moved all our stuff over to our new room and they did it all for us for nothing. I told them we were grateful and would pay something but they refused. A phenomenal experience. The upgrade provided just enough distance between the two kids, that we had great nights sleep and a fantastic trip. We absolutely loved our stay there and are so grateful to Chris and the OKW staff for making it possible for us to enjoy our trip ro Disney.

5/5 4/5 3/5 12/15 4/5 8/10 4/10
  • Rating: 76%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 20/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? No
  • Value for the Money: 8/10

  • Overall Impression: Overall OKW was an attractive location. Good atmosphere. It was just so big. I am glad we had the opportunity to stay once.

4/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 96%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Truly feels like home and very relaxing. Really nice clean and bright rooms with a great shower. Buses have too many stops and there are not many restaurants. Rooms are huge. Can’t wait to stay here again.

5/5 5/5 4/5 15/15 4/5 8/10 4/10
  • Rating: 88%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 8/10
4/5 5/5 4/5 15/15 4/5 8/10 8/10
  • Rating: 93%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10
5/5 5/5 5/5 9/15 4/5 6/10 10/10
  • Rating: 82%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 20/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: While I found the room oddly laid out and not as up-to-date as some other DVC studios, it was fine and did the trick for a short stay where I was mostly just sleeping in the room. Having said that, I love the ambiance of this resort.

4/5 4/5 4/5 12/15 4/5 8/10 4/10
  • Rating: 76%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 20/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Maybe
  • Value for the Money: 8/10

  • Overall Impression: OKW is our Home away..Always good memories..This past trip we were assigned to a 3rd floor level with a view of street(Peninsular way )..Wife and I are in our late 70s and climbing 3 flights of stairs after visiting the Parks ..Not Fun.. Also had issues with Hot water..No magic feeling when we left this year..Maybe take a year off..

5/5 4/5 4/5 12/15 4/5 6/10 8/10
  • Rating: 79%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 20/25
  • Room Decor: 6/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: While it may not be my first choice, Old Key West was a very enjoyable option for our DVC family. The resort could use a quick service location that is of more substance than what is currently available, but we are a family that does not use our kitchen in the room.

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 6/10 8/10
  • Rating: 91%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 8/10

  • Overall Impression: I loved the resort. Plenty to do & was a great escape from rush of the parks.

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 5/5 8/10 8/10
  • Rating: 96%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Love Old key west and I think it is a overlooked resort!

5/5 4/5 3/5 15/15 3/5 8/10 N/A
  • Rating: 91%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Maybe
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Relaxed resort, but VERY spread out. I was not close enough to walk to Main building for a “quick visit”, therefore I never even saw it. (It was super busy trip!) I feel like this resort may be better for those wishing to spend SOME time at the park and relax more than I do ??

2/5 5/5 4/5 15/15 4/5 8/10 8/10
  • Rating: 84%
  • Room Type: Three Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 20/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10
5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 2/5 10/10 N/A
  • Rating: 87%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 15/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Overall, we absolutely loved staying at Old Key West. I don’t think we would want to stay there without a car, but as long as we can go to other hotels for meals and get to community hall and Olivia’s easily with a car, it’s a great resort. We loved the overall key west vibe and found the rooms very relaxing. Though there was a housekeeping oversight, we still greatly enjoyed the amount of space and the look and feel of the resort.

5/5 4/5 4/5 15/15 4/5 8/10 4/10
  • Rating: 85%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 8/10

  • Overall Impression: Stayed in a 2br to accommodate my wife, child, mom, step dad, step brother and myself. Room was immaculate. Enough space and beds for everyone to be comfortable, very clean. Olivia’s is one of our favorite table service restaurants. It was a little cold so didn’t get to enjoy the pools as much. Only drawback is the buses, we waited over a hour one morning at the miller road bus stop for a bus to magic kingdom. Bus still didn’t show up so just took an Uber instead... actually took Uber most the trip because of the long wait time for buses. But overall I would stay here again and it’s a great value for point usage.

2/5 3/5 3/5 3/15 3/5 6/10 2/10
  • Rating: 41%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 5/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? No
  • Value for the Money: 6/10

  • Overall Impression: It's a great space for several people (there were 6 of us) but it's getting run down looking which confuses me as I've been told that they've just done a complete renovation.

5/5 5/5 5/5 12/15 5/5 10/10 2/10
  • Rating: 74%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 10/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: We have stayed here multiple times and have overall great experiences. Great value for the money.Typically fantastic customer service.

5/5 2/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 6/10 8/10
  • Rating: 90%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: All of the cast members we encountered gave 100% and couldn’t have been more friendly with the exception of the front desk. I was surprised by their lack of effort.

5/5 5/5 4/5 15/15 5/5 6/10 4/10
  • Rating: 87%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 8/10

  • Overall Impression: Only choice for a DVC room with 2 beds.

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 5/5 10/10 10/10
  • Rating: 100%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Relaxing resort away from the chaos of the parks, large comfortable villa, best resort on property!

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 8/10 10/10
  • Rating: 83%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 15/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 6/10

  • Overall Impression: I really love OKW and I always feel at home there. It's generally quiet and it's a beautiful resort with very nicely refurbished rooms. We called MouseKeeping about our issue with the room and they sent the manager over. He asked me to point out all of the problem area(s) so that he may address them and then he brought us to a brand new room, which ended up being a slight upgrade because it was one of the bigger studios in a better location. I didn't have to ask for a new room which was nice, he offered it right off the bat. We were already close to the Hospitality House but our new room was right across from it so it was very convenient. Every cast member we encountered was super friendly and the resort grounds and other buildings were clean. I love the Gurgling Suitcase (bar), it's a great place to grab a quick drink (or 2 or 3 or 4...) and you can take it back to your room. The conch fitters there are great too!! I can't wait to stay here again in the future, this resort holds a special place in my heart.

4/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 8/10 4/10
  • Rating: 85%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 20/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: I love OKW. It really is my home away from home. My parents bought in when I was 1 and we have been going ever since. I am now 23 and on this trip they were able to get us this 2 bedroom for myself, my girlfriend and our friends. OKW is a great resort overall. The only thing I would say in that it is a little far away. When we go together that is not an issue as we always rent a car. However with 5 college kids I think we would have been better served being closer to a park or better transportation such as beach club/ board walk or on the monorail loop. However as it was spring break we had to go with our home resort for the 11 month window. I think renting a car and getting to the respite to check in earlier would be the only thing I would change about the trip.

4/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 6/10 10/10
  • Rating: 94%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Really liked it

5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 97%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Great resort! Beautiful, quiet, enormous rooms and Olivia's! QS option is limited and the bus system is a little longer than most resorts but my family loves this place!

4/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 5/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 97%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10
5/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 2/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 87%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 6/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 6/10

  • Overall Impression: We love Old Key West for its ambiance and charm, the peace and quiet, lush landscaping, charming architecture, and amenities. It's our second favorite resort after Animal Kingdom Lodge.

5/5 5/5 4/5 15/15 4/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 92%
  • Room Type: Studio
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 8/10
4/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 5/5 10/10 8/10
  • Rating: 97%
  • Room Type: Two Bedroom Vacation home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 10/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10
4/5 5/5 5/5 15/15 4/5 10/10 10/10
  • Rating: 96%
  • Room Type: One Bedroom Vacation Home
  • Room Cleanliness: 25/25
  • Room Decor: 8/10
  • Would you stay here again in future? Yes
  • Value for the Money: 10/10

  • Overall Impression: Old Key West has been our go-to since we became DVC members. This trip just solidified our choice.




Discrepancies or Corrections? Please let us know.