While I am a lover of almost all things Disney merchandise, even my enthusiasm has its limits. It isn’t often that we meet to discuss products in this headspace, but every so often, something rolls out that demands attention for all the wrong reasons. As soon as I saw this latest release, I knew I had to share it with you, the newest resident of the Merch Miss List. Meet the Marvel Mystery Foam Ice Cream Toy.
Marvel Mystery Foam Ice Cream Toy: $14.99
When it comes to the cutest Marvel collectibles ever, these Mystery Foam Ice Cream Toys have the competition licked. Six of your favorite Marvel heroes, including Black Panther, Hulk and Thor have been reimagined as colorful ice creams on a stick. Each blind pack includes one of the six characters from the series, but you won’t know which one you have until you open the bag! They’re sure to melt the hearts of Marvel fans everywhere!
Magic in the Details:
- Detailed foam figures on sticks
- Blind pack contains one of six Marvel Mystery Foam Ice Cream Toys. You won’t know which one you have until you open the pack*
- Marvel Mystery Foam Ice Cream Toy mystery figures include Black Panther, Captain America, Thor, Loki, Hulk and Scarlet Witch
- Collect all six* figures in the Marvel Mystery Foam Ice Cream Toys series, each sold separately
* Please note: Specific designs cannot be requested. Due to the unique nature of this item, there are no refunds, exchanges, or returns.The bare necessities
- Ages 3+
- Polyurethane / PP
- Up to 4 3/5” H
- Imported

For only $14.99, you (or your child) can take home a piece of Super Hero-shaped foam to, brace yourself, pretend lick like ice cream? Yes, it’s a toy you can’t really play with and a food item you can’t actually eat, wrapped up in a mystery pack where you probably won’t even get the one you wanted. It’s the perfect storm of impracticality, confusion, and disappointment. And while I try to find the charm in most Disney releases, this one is firmly in the “miss” category. There’s whimsical, and then there’s whatever this is.
The Merch Miss List has had some unforgettable honorees over time, and this new addition joins an illustrious lineup. Past recipients include Disney’s Mix Itz, the baffling plush collection featuring mix-and-match helmets (for reasons still unknown), as well as the giant plush hats that somehow became the headwear of choice in the 100-degree Florida heat earlier this year. I’m still recovering from the sight of guests parading through Magic Kingdom under what looked like oversized stuffed animals. I was speechless then, and I might be again now.
If you’ve been on the hunt for a foam dessert you can’t eat, or a superhero head on a stick, congratulations, your time has come. For everyone else, this one’s a miss.



