As if we needed another reason to visit Gideon’s Bakehouse at Disney Springs, they’ve gone and made their famous Hot Cookie Hour even more tempting. Their newest creation is called the Hallowed Trinity, and it combines three things that really have no business being this irresistible together: warm cookies, chocolate cake, and ice cream.
Let us be honest with you. We think our Cookies are best cooled. Why? Because you can taste all the intended flavors. Hot Cookies push one flavor forward, and that is Chocolate. But we hear you, and we want you happy. We know you sneak behind our backs and put your cookies in the microwave. We want to stop that crime to our cookie by giving you a chance to enjoy our Classic Chocolate Chip straight from the oven every day between 2 pm and 3 pm and then again between 7 pm and 8 pm! Served with or without Homemade Ice Cream. $6-$10 ~Gideon’s Bakehouse Menu
Gideon’s teamed up with local favorite Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream to create this over-the-top dessert, which starts with a freshly baked Gideon’s Chocolate Chip Cookie. But instead of stopping there, they pile on a special ice cream creation loaded with all kinds of chocolatey goodness.
The Hallowed Trinity features Kelly’s signature vanilla ice cream mixed with generous chunks of Gideon’s Chocolate Cake, ribbons of Hot Chocolate Marshmallow Buttercream, and hand-cut pieces of dark chocolate. All of that gets served on top of a warm Chocolate Chip Cookie.
I mean, LOOK at that thing!
If you’ve never experienced Hot Cookie Hour at Gideon’s, it’s a daily tradition that’s been around since the Disney Springs location first opened. During two designated windows each day, guests can enjoy Gideon’s signature Chocolate Chip Cookie served warm from the oven.
And now, thanks to this collaboration with Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream, there’s a whole new way to enjoy it.
When Can You Get the Hallowed Trinity?
The new Hallowed Trinity ice cream upgrade is available during Gideon’s daily Hot Cookie Hour at Disney Springs:
- Afternoon: 2:00 to 3:00 p.m.
- Evening: 7:00 to 8:00 p.m.
This collaboration also supports another Central Florida business. Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream has several locations throughout the Orlando area, and Gideon’s highlighted the partnership in its announcement.
Between the warm cookie, chunks of chocolate cake, and that marshmallow buttercream, this might be one of the most outrageous new desserts we’ve seen at Disney Springs in a while. And considering the competition, that’s saying something.
Now the only question is whether we’d actually be willing to share one. I’m thinking probably not.



