Today, The Walt Disney Company won a preliminary injunction that forces Redbox to stop selling digital download codes of Disney movies.
Redbox, which has rental kiosks at stores throughout the U.S., had made a practice of purchasing Disney movies in a package that included a DVD, Blu-ray disc, and a digital download code. Redbox would then rent the Blu-Ray and DVD to consumers, plus SELL the download code separately.
Disney claimed that the Redbox was violating copyright laws by reselling the download codes and filed a lawsuit in late 2017. Disney also discouraged large national retailers from selling their movies to Redbox, prompting Redbox to respond with its own lawsuit claiming copyright misuse and unfair business practices.
U.S. District Court Judge Dean Pregerson initially sided with Redbox, writing in a January decision said that Disney’s package was not clear enough and that Disney was “improperly leveraging digital content to restrict secondary transfers of physical copies.”
Since that decision, Disney has changed the language on their packaging, specifically saying that the “digital code in this package may not be sold separately.”
Today, Pregerson sided with Disney…and their new packaging, writing that any copyright misuse defense by Redbox is now unlikely to succeed and granting a preliminary injunction stopping the sale of the digital codes for Disney movies by Redbox.
Source: The Hollywood Reporter
Tom is the host and producer of the DIS Unplugged: Disneyland Edition podcast, plus Disneyland Editor of The DIS. He enjoys traveling with his wife and teenage son. At this point, their favorite destination is Alaska, with a FIFTH cruise there planned for the Summer of 2019. In his spare time he volunteers with Boy Scouts and Cub Scouts, and help found his son's former Cub Scout Pack. His favorite Disneyland attraction is Space Mountain.